A Review of the Libyan Legislator's Position on the Majority System and the Proportional Representation System in Legislative Council Elections

  • Fathllah Musbah Oran Muftah Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, Al-Zaytouna University, Tarhuna - Libya.
  • Bader Meelad Aqeelah Aljamal Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, Bani Waleed University, Bani Walid - Libya.
DOI https://doi.org/10.58916/alhaq.vi.232
Published: 2024-12-01
تحميل pdf (Arabic)
216
77

Abstract

In this study، I analyzed the majority system and the proportional representation system in elections and the position of the Libyan legislator towards them. The study aimed to investigate the effects of adopting one of these two systems in relation to achieving a set of goals، the most important of which are political stability، fair representation of the popular will، and the size of popular participation. It became clear to us that the majority system leads to the priority of achieving the goal of political stability، forming an effective ruling authority، over the goal of fair representation and increasing the size of popular participation، unlike the proportional representation system، which often leads to the distribution of seats in elected councils to all political spectrums in a fair manner according to the number of votes obtained. The study also concluded that adopting the single non-transferable vote system in the electoral system leads to the dispersion of votes supporting the party or the political entity، as well as some candidates obtaining seats with a small number of votes as a result of their concentration on some candidates.  The study also addressed the position of the Libyan legislator on the departure from the list system in favor of the individual system، which in turn led to the adoption of the majority system in the House of Representatives elections، which led to a decline in the role of parties in political life، and was negatively reflected in the size of popular participation in the House elections. The study recommended the necessity of adopting a mixed electoral system that combines the two systems according to the single transferable vote system

Keywords: Proportional Relative Majority Absolute Majority Majority System Electoral Systems Representation System.

How to Cite

Fathllah Musbah Oran Muftah, & Bader Meelad Aqeelah Aljamal. (2024). A Review of the Libyan Legislator’s Position on the Majority System and the Proportional Representation System in Legislative Council Elections. مجلة الحق للعلوم الشرعية والقانونية, 10-21. https://doi.org/10.58916/alhaq.vi.232
Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Issue

v11i22024

Section

Articles

References

1.
References
2.
- Bushnafa Shamsa, Electoral Systems, Their Impact and Relationship to Party Systems, Politics and Law Notebooks, Special Issue, April, 2011
3.
- Duaa Qasim Amhaibish, The Electoral System in Iraq 2010 The Problem of Multiple Constituencies, Journal of (International Studies), Issue 99 for the year 2024, 09.
4.
- Khadir Yassin Al-Ghanimi, Electoral Systems and Vote Counting and Their Impact on Democratic Systems, an Analytical Study between Theoretical Text and Practical Application) Iraq as a Model (Ahlulbayt Magazine, Peace Be Upon Them).
5.
- Hamad Al-Shoubaki, The Palestinian Electoral System, a Comparative Analytical Study, Journal of Law, Politics and Social Sciences, Volume 2, Issue 2, 2023.
6.
- Saleh Al-Khawaldeh, The Electoral System in Jordan for the Year 2016 "An Analytical Study" Algerian Journal of Human Security, Issue 3, January 2017.
7.
- Salah Al-Din Fawzi, The Ocean in Political Systems and Constitutional Law, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2000. Issue 3, January 2017.
8.
- Abdeen Al-Sharif, Radhia Al-Maadani, History of Elections in Libya 1877-2014, General Authority for Culture, First Edition, National Library, Benghazi, Libya, 2018
9.
- Abdul Hakim Muhammad Arwiha, Election as a Means of Supporting Power, Journal of Legal Research, Misurata University, Faculty of Law, Third Year, First Issue, October, 2015.
10.
- Abdo Hamoud Al-Sharif, "Electoral Models and Their Applications in Contemporary Political Systems", Electoral Systems and the Future of Democracy in the Republic of Yemen: Research and Discussions of the Symposium Held in Sana'a 16-17/1992, Publications of the General People's Congress - Sana'a University Branch, 1999.
11.
- Awad Al-Limon, Political Systems and Principles of Constitutional Law, Second Edition, Wael Publishing House, 2016.
12.
- Qaddour Zarif, Provisions of the Majority Election System and the Proportional Representation Election System Under Organic Law No. 08/19 Amended and Supplemented, Al-Bahthan Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, Issue Three, June 2020.
13.
- Laila Dragh, The Electoral System and Its Impact on the Participation of Political Parties in Algeria, Al-Bahthan Journal of Academic Studies, Volume 07, Issue 01 - for the year 2020.
14.
-Hadi Harb, Report on the Impact of the Electoral System on the Oversight Performance of the Legislative Council. The Palestinian Independent Commission for Citizens’ Rights, Legal Reports Series 1011-018.
15.
-Kurunczi Gábor. (2022) ‘Electoral Systems’ in Csink، L.، Trócsányi، L. (eds.) Comparative Constitutionalism in Central Europe: Analysis on Certain Central and Eastern European Countries. Miskolc– Budapest: Central European Academic Publishing. pp. 425–426. https://doi.org/10.54171/2022. lcslt.ccice_22
16.
-Indridason, I. H. (2011). Proportional representation, majoritarian legislatures. and coalitional voting. American Journal of Political Science, 55(4).
17.
-Piolatto, A. (2011). Plurality versus proportional electoral rule: Which is most representative of voters?. European Journal of Political Economy, 27(2),.
18.
- Websites:
19.
- The website of the High National Elections Commission, at the following link: https://hnec.ly.
20.
- Report on the General National Congress Elections in Libya, issued on July 7, 2012, a report issued by the Carter Center, www.CARTERCENTER.ORG.
21.
Laws:
22.
- Law No. 4 of 2012 regarding the National Congress Elections issued by the National Transitional Council on 01-28-2012.
23.
- Law No. 10 of 2014 regarding the House of Representatives Elections issued by the National Congress on 03-31-2014.

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

Similar Articles

1-10 of 48

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.